Friday, 30 May 2014

This guy just stole pi, and Zazzle helped him do it.

[Edit 30/05 10:00am AEST: It seems Zazzle have listened to reason and are reinstating products. Here's my update.]

Designers are in uproar and filing counter notices after print company Zazzle upheld a man's claim to own the pi symbol on clothing.

Paul Ingrisano, a pirate living in Brooklyn New York, filed a trademark under "Pi Productions" for a logo which consists of this freely available version of the pi symbol π from the Wikimedia website combined with a period (full stop). The conditions of the trademark specifically state that the trademark includes a period.

The Pirate Who Stole Pi

The trademark was granted in January 2014 and Ingrisano has recently made trademark infringement claims against a massive range of pi-related designs on print-on-demand websites including Zazzle and Cafepress.

The Wikimedia Commons pi symbol
Surprisingly, Zazzle accepted his claim and removed thousands of clothing products using this design, emailing designers that their work was infringing Pi Productions' intellectual property - even designs not using a full stop.

At first Zazzle's Content Review team responded to their very angry designers and store keepers with generic emails, suggesting they file counter notices if they felt aggrieved.

But now Zazzle's latest response is that they are acting to protect Paul Ingrisano's "intellectual property" from "confusingly similar" designs as under the Lanham Act 1946 - including designs which do not even contain the pi symbol, but just the word "pi" in their design name.

Pi Productions' "trademark"
Zazzle have locked a public forum thread where angry designers were demanding explanations and discussing legal action, saying they removed apparel designs while they "evaluate the complaint".


There are huge implications for designers and individuals across the planet. If Zazzle wash their hands and accept one man's claim to own the rights to all use of an ancient greek letter and generic mathematical symbol on clothing, it sets a precedent for other websites and companies to do the same.

The story bears similarity to the Sweet Pea trademark case where a $16 million lawsuit was filed against 52 small independent retailers, claiming the phrase "sweet pea" was a trademark. The defendants won the case, highlighting how trademark law can be abused.

Obviously companies like Zazzle have to take trademark infringement claims very seriously.

But if they really did take it seriously, wouldn't they realise how spurious and fraudulent claiming a mathematical symbol is?

These frauds want to dictate what you can wear

Paul Ingrisano's next target: "I <3"
Currently "published for opposition"
Pirates like Ingrisano operate exactly like pirates of the old days: taking opportunities to steal and scaring people into giving them what they want. His latest trademark application is a stylised version of "I <3", a commonly-used text expression on the internet and T-shirt designs. If granted he will no doubt use it to threaten print-on-demand sites and take down another whole fleet of legitimate designs.

Even if Ingrisano had any basis to his Zazzle claim, he is not actually selling any products with this logo. The only one on the entire internet is this skull picture on his Etsy account. [Edit: Despite looking pretty thoroughly, I couldn't find Pi Productions' online store. Thanks to Artnet who found it with "a quick search".]

He is not a legitimate business concerned about his property - he is a pirate out to bully and disrupt legitimate designers.

But while Ingrisano is a pirate, Zazzle are in the position of having made a monumental screw-up - and are working their hardest to justify their mistake, instead of admitting they made one.

Minimum human judgement

Print-on-demand websites are bombarded by these fraudulent claims every day, and most are rightly dismissed. But sites like Zazzle are so terrified of lawsuits, they often automate their content review process. The Cafepress upload system will not even publish any designs referencing intellectual property like Lord Of The Rings or Star Wars.

This means real human judgement is reduced to a bare minimum. And with an army of frauds like Ingrisano firing constant claims, it was a matter of time before a company made a poor judgement out of fear - even despite the clear and obvious fact you cannot trademark a generic symbol or letter.

That company is Zazzle, and instead of admitting their error, they are helping Ingrisano steal pi.

Furious reaction

Some furious designers have already filed counter-notices, which - if not responded to within 14 days - mean Zazzle must reinstate the designs.

And some are discussing class action lawsuit to recover lost earnings. Every day these legitimate designs are offline is lost income for dozens, even hundreds, of small independent designers on Zazzle.

Angry blog posts and tweets are appearing from people who are infuriated that Zazzle would bow down to to such an obviously unjustified trademark claim.

And it doesn't just affect designers - the implications affect scientists, mathematicians, classrooms, college fraternities.

With something as generic and as popular as the pi symbol - which has its own day on 14th March - it's quite possible this issue will hit sites like Reddit and io9 and I F**king Love Science, and from there up to the mainstream news channels. If it does, Zazzle will be shown to be very stupid, and there'll be a lot more angry people on the internet.

I'm a Zazzle designer. Yes, I would like my products reinstated, and it would be nice for any lost earnings to be compensated. But mainly, I just want Zazzle to admit they messed up, big-time.

What I want from Zazzle is an apology.

[Edit 30/05 10:00am AEST: It seems Zazzle have listened to reason and are reinstating products. Here's my update.]


  1. Oh this is good. Shared.
    I'd like to start a collection of designs people had pulled already.
    I'd be happy to put together such a page if you like. Anyone who wants an image included please either post it here, or give me a link to it.

    Here are the two of mine that got pulled.
    MY images

    That square version (I had to dig up the file generated in 2008) uses Times New Roman as the font. SAME as this pi guy. Hardly a "stylized" version as in his description.

    Just got done sending Zazzle some 30 reinstatement requests.

    1. It looks like LaTeX (upgreek+Adobe Symbol) to me:

  2. Fraternities generally already have their own trademark of their letters, so they shouldn't be affected. I suspect Ingrisano will stick to picking off the easier targets than going after entities already armed with lawyers to protect their own trademarks.

    There is another, less immediately obvious cost to designers: the irreplaceable link history associated with their designs that drives traffic to their online stores. Even if they're eventually allowed to upload their designs again, there is no way I know of to regain that link history, potentially costing designers even more than the loss of sales for just their pi-specific designs.

    I'm worried about his attempt to trademark "I 3>", as I suspect he might target my "eye heart" designs, even though they bear no resemblance to this. It seems he's laboring under the impression that he can trademark not only the logo, but an entire concept. That Zazzle is enabling his success at that is really a bad move on their part.


  3. Ya know I don't even want an apology. I understand their initial phase. No one wants to go though a lawsuit. I'd just like them to "evaluate it" and let us put our products back up.

  4. PIss poor and typical patent troll

  5. I tried posting this before, so apologies if it comes up twice.
    Is it not possible for POD designers to join together (world wide would be great) as a group, to be big enough to go up against jerks like this? With or without legal representation, there is a certain power in large groups. And since the POD makers, for the most part, can't or won't do this...

    Also, I also sell on Skreened here in the US. They still print my co-exist shirts (which zazzle and cafepress both wimped out on). Great shirts, print all over them. Good quality, too.

    1. Skreened is a small local company. We know the guy who owns it. They fly under the radar of a lot of these patent trolls.

  6. What goes around comes around.

  7. Ah the I <3 trademark will now read basically 'apparel except! what Reebok makes'.
    What a bozo!

  8. Your misuse of the word pirate is annoying.

  9. zazzle is restoring pi products. There's a notice in the create products section of their forums.

    1. Thanks for the update - will check it out

    2. Btw, do you have a link for any reinstated products? Was there an announcement, or did you receive an email? I haven't heard anything yet myself.

    3. You probably already found it, but it's in the create products category:

    4. Aye indeed, all up to speed now. Thanks :)

  10. Yeah for Zazzle - and they did keep our products, just hid them really good! They are reinstating them, we don' tneed to do anything.

    1. Thanks for the update - will check it out

  11. Save the world?! How could you ever want to unless you yourself were the badger? Kindergarden wasn't a high heel step away from uselessness was it? Get out of the limelight Sharon Stone and start counting your blessings!

    1. "???" Well exactly. I normally delete spam, but there's no link, and this one is so wonderfully odd.

  12. YEA zazzle saw the light.
    This is the email I got.

    Hello Zazzler,

    Thanks to all of you for your patience while we evaluated the claim we received regarding the trademark with registration number 4473631.

    After reviewing the take-down request more closely, Zazzle has decided to restore “Pi” products as of today. Zazzle is a marketplace for a community of artists, and we want to continue to support artists who are creating original artwork.

    Products are being reinstated right now, so it may take a few hours for the products to appear on the Zazzle site. For those of you whose products were affected, we especially appreciate your feedback and patience these past few days. Rest assured that no action is needed on your part for your products to be fully reinstated.

    Thanks again!

  13. Zazzle screwed up, no doubt. But at least they admitted it and fixed their mistake. Good for them. Many companies would just say forget it. Others would say (and have said, "We're sorry... you may go ahead and spend 18 hours reposting all the items we took down." I think they got hammered on this one pretty bad and responded appropriately.

  14. Idiotic... that's what this is. Idiotic. I get that they may have an obligation to remove "any similar marks that is likely to result in consumer confusion as part of the Lanham Act", but using it as it refers to the ratio of the circumference of a circle to its diameter is no more likely to "result in consumer confusion" in a way that can actually be upheld by trademark than a glass company that makes custom windows can be confusing people with an operating system made by Microsoft.

  15. Wow/ Glad to hear how stupid this was. I was livid when I received emails from Zazzle stating that I had my EPIC PI t-shirt designs removed because of this mess. Zazzle sucks, that's all that I'm going to say about them. There's a tshirt design for you. :)

  16. I am afraid the Law office of Ronald Millet shall be called upon to cease and desist in its practice of sending any and all letters, emails, notes, notices, or notifications that include the following trademarks: the letter f (owned by Facebiook); the letter p (owned by Pinterest); the letter s (owned by Skype), the letter z (owned by Zazzle); the letter Q (owned by Quicken); the letter B (owned by the Boston Red Sox) ... need we continue?


  18. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  19. "They could be Jews because they are the only people with enough arrogance to do something like that." Are you for real? I'm not having anti-Semitic shit in my blog comments. Delete.
    There's plenty of info on Paul Ingrisano and Pi Productions on the various articles going around. He sells shirts primarily through physical shops in Brooklyn NY.

    Work from home theory is fast gaining popularity because of the freedom and flexibility that comes with it. Since one is not bound by fixed working hours, they can schedule their work at the time when they feel most productive and convenient to them. Women & Men benefit a lot from this concept of work since they can balance their home and work perfectly. People mostly find that in this situation, their productivity is higher and stress levels lower. Those who like isolation and a tranquil work environment also tend to prefer this way of working. Today, with the kind of communication networks available, millions of people worldwide are considering this option.

    Women & Men who want to be independent but cannot afford to leave their responsibilities at home aside will benefit a lot from this concept of work. It makes it easier to maintain a healthy balance between home and work. The family doesn't get neglected and you can get your work done too. You can thus effectively juggle home responsibilities with your career. Working from home is definitely a viable option but it also needs a lot of hard work and discipline. You have to make a time schedule for yourself and stick to it. There will be a time frame of course for any job you take up and you have to fulfill that project within that time frame.

    There are many things that can be done working from home. A few of them is listed below that will give you a general idea about the benefits of this concept.

    This is the most common and highly preferred job that Women & Men like doing. Since in today's competitive world both the parents have to work they need a secure place to leave behind their children who will take care of them and parents can also relax without being worried all the time. In this job you don't require any degree or qualifications. You only have to know how to take care of children. Parents are happy to pay handsome salary and you can also earn a lot without putting too much of an effort.

    For those who have a garden or an open space at your disposal and are also interested in gardening can go for this method of earning money. If given proper time and efforts nursery business can flourish very well and you will earn handsomely. But just as all jobs establishing it will be a bit difficult but the end results are outstanding.

    Freelance can be in different wings. Either you can be a freelance reporter or a freelance photographer. You can also do designing or be in the advertising field doing project on your own. Being independent and working independently will depend on your field of work and the availability of its worth in the market. If you like doing jewellery designing you can do that at home totally independently. You can also work on freelancing as a marketing executive working from home. Wanna know more, email us on and we will send you information on how you can actually work as a marketing freelancer.

    Internet related work
    This is a very vast field and here sky is the limit. All you need is a computer and Internet facility. Whatever field you are into work at home is perfect match in the software field. You can match your time according to your convenience and complete whatever projects you get. To learn more about how to work from home, contact us today on workfromhome.otr214423@gmail.comand our team will get you started on some excellent work from home projects.

    Diet food
    Since now a days Women & Men are more conscious of the food that they eat hence they prefer to have homemade low cal food and if you can start supplying low cal food to various offices then it will be a very good source of income and not too much of efforts. You can hire a few ladies who will help you out and this can be a good business.

    Thus think over this concept and go ahead.

  21. OFF TOPIC> I've noticed a big drop in sales in my Zazzle acct. I was selling on average 5 shirts a day, and now I'm selling 1, or 2 if I'm lucky. This makes no sense as I have twice the amt of products than I did when I was selling 5 shirts a day. Has anyone else noticed a drop in sales over the past year? Would it be possible that Zazzle would be withholding commission and not reporting all sales to their designers?